Forced Arbitration — a service of Madgett Law, LLC, a Minnesota law firm. It is not a government agency, is not affiliated with the Minnesota Attorney General or any other government office, and is not a legal aid or public interest legal services organization.

The database

About the data

What is in the clause database, where each value comes from, and what the database does not claim.

What the database is

139 documents: consumer agreements located on the companies' own sites (or, where a page would not load, an archived snapshot, the CFPB's credit card agreement database or a copy on a state agency's website), fetched from a U.S. address, hashed, and saved with the time of capture. 110 documents contain an arbitration clause and 29 documents do not. The reviewed categories and quotations are what this site publishes.

It is not a random sample, not a census, and not a measure of the American consumer contract population. Companies were selected by U.S. consumer reach within each sector, largest first, plus companies headquartered in or heavily serving Minnesota within each sector. Which document was captured matters: a website's terms of use are often not the contract that binds a customer, and each document page says what was captured.

Reviewed categories, not machine flags

The research first produced a machine flag for every field — a present/absent mark set by pattern-matching over each extraction. Rows marked silent were reviewed against the full captured text; silence is recorded only where no provision on that field was found. What is published is the reviewer's category and the document's own words. A category is a label for what the quotation says; it is not a grade, and the site does not rank companies by it.

silent means that no provision on that field was extracted from the captured text, and nothing is quoted for it.

Two categories are shown in their field's list and are not counted toward the finding the field is usually read for. In the words of the category definitions:

  • no-preclusive-effect-clause — 21 documents: A term that limits what an award does in other cases (no preclusive effect, no precedential value, not binding on others, may not be used or admitted elsewhere) is no-preclusive-effect-clause: shown in the partition, never counted as confidentiality.
  • anti-consolidation-only — 33 documents: anti-consolidation-only — a bare ban on joining or consolidating claims — is its own category in mass_arbitration_terms and is not counted as mass-arbitration procedure.

Fields whose text was not captured

Four exclusion labels — not-captured, incorporated-terms-not-captured, partial-capture, opt-out-referenced-terms-not-captured — are shown in every partition and excluded from every count that assumes the text was read. The test is whether the text on which the field depends was read, not whether the document is awkward.

5 documents (5 families) carry a field recorded as not read: 37 of the 1540 reviewed rows across the 110 documents with a clause. 4 of those documents' pages carry the reviewed record's own note on what was and was not captured; each shows the field as not captured with the document's own words where the record has them.

  • not-captured — The arbitration agreement itself was not captured, so the field was not read.
  • incorporated-terms-not-captured — The terms on this field are in an incorporated document that was not captured, so the field was not read.
  • partial-capture — The part of the document that would answer this field was not captured, so the field was not read.
  • opt-out-referenced-terms-not-captured — The captured page refers to an opt-out whose terms are in an agreement that was not captured.

Documents and corporate families

A count on this site is by document — one captured agreement — unless it says families. Four corporate families hold more than one document in the dataset, so the 139 documents are 135 families, the 110 documents with a clause are 107 families, and the 29 documents without are 28 families. The families, which are the report's own definition, are:

  • PayPal Holdings: PayPal — PayPal User Agreement; Venmo — User Agreement
  • Synchrony Financial: Synchrony Bank — AEO, Inc. Credit Card Account Agreement; CareCredit — CARECREDIT CREDIT CARD ACCOUNT AGREEMENT
  • JPMorgan Chase: Chase — Deposit Account Agreement and Privacy Notice; Chase — Zelle® Service Agreement and Privacy Notice
  • Big Picture Loans: Big Picture Loans — Terms of Website Use; Big Picture Loans — Tribal Dispute Resolution Procedure page

Duplicates

Two research passes captured the same document from the same URL once; the research folder records the pair and the copy excluded from every count. The build re-checks every document against every other by source URL and by a hash of its normalized text, and refuses to run if a pair appears that the record does not resolve.

How every quotation was checked

Every quotation in the clause database was checked, at build time, against the text of record of the document it is attributed to: 1292 quotations checked, 0 mismatches. The comparison folds curly quotation marks and apostrophes to straight ones and non-breaking spaces to ordinary spaces, removes zero-width spaces, maps the ligature characters that PDF text extraction introduces to their letters, and reduces every run of whitespace to one space; after that the quotation must appear exactly — letter case, dashes and punctuation included — and there is no looser fallback. An ellipsis in a quotation marks text left out of it, and each part on either side of the ellipsis must appear in the text of record, in the same order. 736 quotations of the 1292 that verify are literal substrings of the text of record before any of that normalization; 321 are literal substrings once runs of whitespace are reduced to one space, before any other normalization; the remaining 235 quotations match only after the rest of it, or across an ellipsis. If a quotation fails, the build stops and nothing is published; no quotation is edited to make it match.

The build then checks its own output: every quotation rendered on a page is read back and compared to the data file it came from, and to the text of record, and every quotation carries the source URL of the document as its citation.

The documents without a clause

A document is recorded as having no arbitration clause only when a search of its full captured text for the word finds nothing, or finds it only outside an agreement to arbitrate (a severability clause, a description of another product's terms) or only in a version of the terms not yet in force on the capture date (X Corp.), and the dispute and governing-law sections have been read to confirm it. Each such document has its own page here, with its capture date and hash, so the finding can be checked against the same evidence as everything else.

The reviewed fields

A fifteenth item, the mass-arbitration numeric trigger, was reviewed separately for every clause-bearing document: whether the clause states a number of similar demands at which special procedures apply, and if so what number, what unit, what window, and whether the trigger is conditioned on the claimants sharing counsel. 50 documents (49 families) state a number.

Every reviewed category, with how many documents carry it

Where a category has a definition, or a rule for how it is counted, the definition or the rule follows the count, in the words of the category definitions. A category marked not captured is shown in every partition and excluded from every count that assumes the text was read.

Delegation clause (who decides whether the clause is enforceable)
  • to-arbitrator-full — 25 documents — The arbitrator decides whether the arbitration clause is valid, enforceable and applies, with no question reserved to a court.
  • to-court — 25 documents — A court decides whether the arbitration clause is valid, enforceable and applies.
  • to-arbitrator-except-class-waiver — 23 documents — The arbitrator decides those questions, except that a court decides the class-action waiver.
  • silent — 15 documents — The captured text has no provision on this field.
  • to-arbitrator-except-procedural — 10 documents — The arbitrator decides those questions, except that a court decides a stated procedural question (such as compliance with a pre-filing step or which version of the terms applies).
  • to-court-but-whole-contract-to-arbitrator — 7 documents — A court decides challenges to the arbitration clause; the arbitrator decides challenges to the contract as a whole.
  • class-waiver-question-to-arbitrator-only — 1 document — The document assigns only the class-waiver question, to the arbitrator.
  • class-waiver-question-to-court-only — 1 document — The document assigns only the class-waiver question, to a court.
  • not-captured — 1 document (not captured) — The arbitration agreement itself was not captured, so the field was not read.
  • partial-capture — 1 document (not captured) — The part of the document that would answer this field was not captured, so the field was not read.
  • split-formation-to-court — 1 document — A court decides only whether an agreement to arbitrate was formed; the arbitrator decides the rest.
Consumer’s share of arbitration fees
  • provider-rules-only-no-cap — 37 documents — The provider's rules or fee schedule, the arbitrator or the law set the consumer's share; the document states no cap and commits the company to no payment on the consumer's claim (a promise only to consider a request does not count).
  • company-pays-part-or-on-conditions — 18 documents — Whatever the claim's value, the company pays part of the consumer's share, or pays it on a request, a showing or an outcome, and the document states no cap.
  • silent — 12 documents — The captured text has no provision on this field.
  • company-pays-share-below-stated-claim-value — 11 documents — The company pays or reimburses all or part of the consumer's share only on claims up to a stated value; the provider's rules govern otherwise.
  • filing-fee-paid-or-reimbursed — 8 documents — The company pays, advances or reimburses the consumer's filing fee (in full, up to a stated amount, or on stated conditions); other fees follow the provider's rules.
  • capped-at-stated-amount — 6 documents — The consumer's share of all arbitration fees is capped at a stated dollar amount or at the provider's consumer filing fee, whatever the claim's value.
  • filing-fee-capped-at-court-fee — 5 documents — Only the filing fee is capped at the court filing fee; other fees follow the provider's rules.
  • capped-at-court-filing-fee — 4 documents — The consumer's share of all arbitration fees is capped at what filing in court would cost, whatever the claim's value.
  • company-pays-all — 4 documents — On a claim the consumer brings, the company pays or reimburses all arbitration fees, whatever the claim's value, on the conditions stated.
  • each-side-bears-own-attorney-fees — 2 documents — The document allocates no arbitration fees; its only term is that each side bears its own attorney's fees.
  • incorporated-terms-not-captured — 1 document (not captured) — The terms on this field are in an incorporated document that was not captured, so the field was not read.
  • mass-filing-fee-term-only — 1 document — The document's only fee term applies to mass filings; it states no allocation for an individual arbitration.
  • not-captured — 1 document (not captured) — The arbitration agreement itself was not captured, so the field was not read.
Company’s fee promise
  • silent — 24 documents — The captured text has no provision on this field.
  • hardship-or-request-conditioned — 17 documents — The company pays some or all of the consumer's fees if the consumer asks, or on a showing or finding of hardship or excessive cost.
  • award-floor-or-bonus-tied-to-settlement-offer — 11 documents — The consumer receives a minimum award or a bonus if the award beats the company's last settlement offer.
  • mass-proceeding-fees-only — 10 documents — The company pays only fees that arise in a mass proceeding (such as a mediator or procedural arbitrator).
  • reimburses-filing-fee — 10 documents — The company pays or reimburses the filing fee, or fees the consumer paid, on the conditions stated.
  • pays-all-arbitration-fees — 7 documents — The company pays the arbitration fees, apart from any filing fee or claim-value limit the document states.
  • pays-only-if-company-initiates — 7 documents — The company pays the fees only in an arbitration it starts.
  • pays-all-unless-frivolous — 5 documents — The company pays the arbitration fees unless the claim is found frivolous, in bad faith or improper.
  • pays-only-where-required-by-law — 3 documents — The company pays only where the law requires it (not counted as a promise).
  • award-floor-tied-to-refused-demand — 2 documents — The consumer receives a minimum award if the award reaches or exceeds relief the consumer demanded and the company refused.
  • discretionary-consideration-only — 2 documents — The company may, but need not, pay or reduce the consumer's share (not counted as a promise).
  • good-faith-cost-cooperation-language — 2 documents — The parties agree to cooperate in good faith on costs (not counted as a promise).
  • pays-costs-plus-fees-if-consumer-wins — 2 documents — The company pays costs and fees if the consumer prevails.
  • advance-recoverable-if-company-prevails — 1 document — The company advances fees that it may recover if it prevails.
  • attorney-fees-paid-if-award-beats-offer — 1 document — The company pays the consumer's attorney's fees if the consumer recovers more than the company offered.
  • incorporated-terms-not-captured — 1 document (not captured) — The terms on this field are in an incorporated document that was not captured, so the field was not read.
  • no-promise-arbitrator-may-award-costs — 1 document — No company promise; the arbitrator may award the consumer costs (not counted as a promise).
  • not-captured — 1 document (not captured) — The arbitration agreement itself was not captured, so the field was not read.
  • pays-arbitrator-and-arbitration-unique-costs-only — 1 document — The company pays the arbitrator and costs unique to arbitration only.
  • pays-filing-fees-plus-capped-attorney-contribution — 1 document — The company pays filing fees and, on a showing, up to a stated amount of attorney's fees.
  • right-to-elect-to-pay-where-required — 1 document — The company may elect to pay where the rules or the law require it (not counted as a promise).
Fee or cost shifting against the consumer
  • frivolous-or-rule-11-only — 32 documents — Fees or costs shift only on a finding that a claim was frivolous, in bad faith or in breach of Rule 11 standards.
  • silent — 23 documents — The captured text has no provision on this field.
  • offer-of-judgment-cost-shift — 18 documents — A party who rejects a settlement offer and then does no better pays the offering party's costs from the offer.
  • court-equivalent-fee-shifting-imported — 6 documents — The arbitrator may shift fees and costs as a court could.
  • one-way-collection-or-enforcement-costs — 6 documents — The only term is a one-way collection or enforcement-cost term outside the dispute-resolution provisions (not counted as a shift in arbitration). — Not counted as fee shifting against the consumer in arbitration; shown separately.
  • provider-fee-rules-apply-if-claim-found-improper — 5 documents — The company's fee promise falls away, and the provider's fee rules apply, if the claim is found frivolous or improper.
  • pre-filing-noncompliance-costs — 4 documents — A party that files without completing the pre-filing steps may be ordered to pay the other side's fees and costs.
  • prevailing-party-fees — 4 documents — The prevailing party recovers its attorney's fees.
  • loser-pays-on-motion-to-compel — 2 documents — The party that loses a motion to compel arbitration pays the other side's costs and fees.
  • company-fee-recovery-if-claim-filed-in-court — 1 document — The company recovers its fees if the consumer sues in court instead of arbitrating.
  • consumer-advances-half-of-fees-in-mass-arbitration — 1 document — In a mass arbitration the consumer must advance half the administrative and arbitrator fees.
  • costs-for-breach-of-dispute-terms — 1 document — A court or arbitrator may order a party that breaches the dispute terms (for example by joining a mass action) to pay the other side's costs and fees.
  • frivolous-then-prevailing-party-fees — 1 document — On a finding of frivolousness, the prevailing party recovers its fees.
  • incorporated-terms-not-captured — 1 document (not captured) — The terms on this field are in an incorporated document that was not captured, so the field was not read.
  • loser-reimburses-advanced-fees — 1 document — A consumer who loses may be ordered to repay fees the company advanced.
  • not-captured — 1 document (not captured) — The arbitration agreement itself was not captured, so the field was not read.
  • partial-capture — 1 document (not captured) — The part of the document that would answer this field was not captured, so the field was not read.
  • pre-filing-noncompliance-dismissal — 1 document — A claim filed without completing the pre-filing steps must be dismissed.
  • prevailing-party-cost-recovery — 1 document — The prevailing party recovers its costs.
Pre-filing requirement
  • mandatory-condition-precedent — 71 documents — Filing is barred until a stated period runs or a stated step is done, or skipping the step has a stated consequence.
  • silent — 20 documents — The captured text has no provision on this field.
  • notice-only-no-waiting-period — 5 documents — The required notice is the demand that starts the arbitration.
  • encouraged-not-required — 2 documents — An informal step is encouraged, not required.
  • company-elects-adr — 1 document — Alternative dispute resolution begins at the company's election.
  • incorporated-terms-not-captured — 1 document (not captured) — The terms on this field are in an incorporated document that was not captured, so the field was not read.
  • informal-no-fixed-period — 1 document — An informal step is required, with no fixed period.
  • mass-arbitration-only-condition — 1 document — A pre-filing condition applies only in mass arbitrations.
  • not-captured — 1 document (not captured) — The arbitration agreement itself was not captured, so the field was not read.
  • notice-conditions-fee-promise — 1 document — The notice conditions the company's fee promise, not the right to file.
  • notice-required — 1 document — A notice must precede filing; no waiting period or consequence is stated.
  • notice-required-no-tolling — 1 document — A notice is required, and the document states that it does not stop limitations periods.
  • optional-external-program — 1 document — An external complaint program is offered, not required.
  • optional-informal-period — 1 document — An informal period is optional.
  • optional-notice-unlocks-minimum-award — 1 document — An optional notice qualifies the consumer for an award floor.
  • partial-capture — 1 document (not captured) — The part of the document that would answer this field was not captured, so the field was not read.
Mass-arbitration terms
  • anti-consolidation-only — 33 documents — A bare ban on joining or consolidating claims (not a mass-arbitration procedure). — anti-consolidation-only — a bare ban on joining or consolidating claims — is its own category in mass_arbitration_terms and is not counted as mass-arbitration procedure.
  • batching — 23 documents — Similar demands are grouped into batches, each decided as one proceeding.
  • staged-bellwether — 19 documents — A set of test cases proceeds first while the rest wait, usually with mediation between rounds.
  • silent — 13 documents — The captured text has no provision on this field.
  • incorporates-provider-rules-only — 9 documents — A provider's mass-arbitration rules or framework apply; the document drafts no batching or bellwether step of its own.
  • bellwether-then-release-to-court — 3 documents — After test cases and mediation, remaining claims can leave arbitration for court, either automatically or on conditions the document states, such as a party's election.
  • mass-filing-fee-terms — 3 documents — The document sets fee terms for mass filings.
  • anti-aggregation-counsel-bar — 2 documents — A bar on filing or joining more than a stated number of demands brought with the same or coordinated representation (a filing bar, not a procedure).
  • mass-action-waiver-no-number-or-procedure — 2 documents — An express mass-action waiver with no number and no procedure.
  • incorporated-terms-not-captured — 1 document (not captured) — The terms on this field are in an incorporated document that was not captured, so the field was not read.
  • mass-action-waiver-plus-sequential-batching — 1 document — An express mass-action waiver, with batching one batch at a time if a mass action proceeds.
  • not-captured — 1 document (not captured) — The arbitration agreement itself was not captured, so the field was not read.
Small-claims carve-out
  • available-standard-carve-out — 85 documents — The consumer may take an individual claim within the court's jurisdiction to small claims court.
  • silent — 18 documents — The captured text has no provision on this field.
  • limited-by-venue-or-condition — 3 documents — Small claims court is available only in a venue the document names, only to some consumers, or only after a stated step.
  • incorporated-terms-not-captured — 1 document (not captured) — The terms on this field are in an incorporated document that was not captured, so the field was not read.
  • not-captured — 1 document (not captured) — The arbitration agreement itself was not captured, so the field was not read.
  • partial-capture — 1 document (not captured) — The part of the document that would answer this field was not captured, so the field was not read.
  • small-claims-referenced-no-carve-out-stated — 1 document — The document refers to small-claims eligibility but states no carve-out.
Opt-out
  • general-with-window — 40 documents — Any consumer may opt out of arbitration within a stated period.
  • silent — 40 documents — The captured text has no provision on this field.
  • change-rejection-only — 7 documents — The consumer may reject later changes to the clause but may not leave arbitration.
  • general-but-class-waiver-survives — 6 documents — Any consumer may opt out within a stated period, but the class-action waiver still applies after the opt-out.
  • new-users-only-30-days — 4 documents — Only new users may opt out, within 30 days.
  • general-with-window-30-days — 3 documents — Any consumer may opt out of arbitration within 30 days.
  • mass-filing-stage-only — 2 documents — An opt-out arises only during a mass arbitration.
  • expressly-none — 1 document — The document states that the consumer's only alternative is not to use the service or to close the account.
  • general-with-window-45-days-but-closed-to-existing-customers — 1 document — New account holders may opt out within 45 days; existing customers may not.
  • general-with-window-60-days — 1 document — Any consumer may opt out of arbitration within 60 days.
  • incorporated-terms-not-captured — 1 document (not captured) — The terms on this field are in an incorporated document that was not captured, so the field was not read.
  • non-consumer-only — 1 document — The opt-out is open only to non-consumer users.
  • opt-out-referenced-terms-not-captured — 1 document (not captured) — The captured page refers to an opt-out whose terms are in an agreement that was not captured.
  • partial-capture — 1 document (not captured) — The part of the document that would answer this field was not captured, so the field was not read.
  • retroactivity-opt-out-only — 1 document — The consumer may decline only the clause's application to earlier claims.
Unilateral modification
  • continued-use-is-acceptance — 40 documents — The company may change the terms, and continued use is acceptance.
  • fresh-rejection-right-per-amendment — 12 documents — The consumer may reject each change to the arbitration clause.
  • consent-required-for-changes — 11 documents — A change binds the consumer only if the consumer agrees to it.
  • notice-then-continued-use — 11 documents — The company gives notice of changes, and continued use after notice is acceptance.
  • effective-on-posting-or-without-notice — 9 documents — Changes take effect on posting or without notice.
  • silent — 6 documents — The captured text has no provision on this field.
  • change-right-mechanism-unstated — 4 documents — The company may change the terms; no mechanism is stated.
  • supersedes-prior-arbitration-agreement — 4 documents — The clause replaces earlier arbitration agreements unless the consumer rejects it.
  • change-by-notice-no-rejection-right — 3 documents — Changes take effect on notice, with no right to reject.
  • new-clause-governs-earlier-claims — 3 documents — A new clause governs earlier claims; the consumer's only way out is to close the account.
  • change-only-in-writing-signed-by-company-officer — 1 document — The contract may be changed only in a writing signed by a company officer.
  • fresh-optout-only-for-substantive-arbitration-changes — 1 document — A new opt-out is offered only for substantive changes to the arbitration clause.
  • material-adverse-amendment-requires-rejection-right — 1 document — A material adverse change requires a right to reject.
  • no-change-sentence-beside-change-procedure — 1 document — A sentence saying the terms will not change stands beside a change procedure.
  • no-less-favorable-change-after-dispute-arises — 1 document — A change does not apply to a claim already noticed.
  • not-captured — 1 document (not captured) — The arbitration agreement itself was not captured, so the field was not read.
  • partial-capture — 1 document (not captured) — The part of the document that would answer this field was not captured, so the field was not read.
Scope
  • broad-plus-survives-termination — 50 documents — The clause reaches claims broadly and survives termination (or reaches claims before and after the agreement).
  • broad-reaches-affiliates-and-third-parties — 40 documents — The clause reaches claims involving affiliates or named third parties.
  • claims-between-the-parties-only — 11 documents — The clause reaches claims between the parties only, naming no affiliate, third party or survival term. — Not counted as broad scope.
  • binds-parent-and-minor — 1 document — The clause binds a parent and a minor.
  • claim-definition-reaches-dealings-with-school — 1 document — The claim definition reaches the consumer's dealings with a school that is not a party.
  • incorporated-terms-not-captured — 1 document (not captured) — The terms on this field are in an incorporated document that was not captured, so the field was not read.
  • not-captured — 1 document (not captured) — The arbitration agreement itself was not captured, so the field was not read.
  • partial-capture — 1 document (not captured) — The part of the document that would answer this field was not captured, so the field was not read.
  • reaches-civil-rights-and-statutory-claims — 1 document — The clause names civil-rights and statutory claims.
  • reaches-debt-buyers-and-collectors — 1 document — Assignees and collectors may enforce the clause.
  • survives-sale-binds-buyer — 1 document — The clause survives a sale of the account and binds the buyer.
  • third-party-beneficiary-named-retailer — 1 document — A named retailer may enforce the clause as a third-party beneficiary.
Confidentiality of the arbitration

Only three categories count as confidentiality of the arbitration: proceeding-confidential, documents-exchanged-confidential, award-only.

  • silent — 47 documents — The captured text has no provision on this field.
  • no-preclusive-effect-clause — 21 documents — An award has limited or no effect in other cases (not confidentiality). — A term that limits what an award does in other cases (no preclusive effect, no precedential value, not binding on others, may not be used or admitted elsewhere) is no-preclusive-effect-clause: shown in the partition, never counted as confidentiality.
  • proceeding-confidential — 18 documents — The arbitration proceeding is confidential.
  • documents-exchanged-confidential — 6 documents — The documents exchanged in the arbitration are confidential.
  • pre-filing-negotiations-only — 5 documents — Only the pre-filing negotiations are confidential.
  • account-information-protection-only — 3 documents — The arbitrator protects account information on request (not confidentiality). — An arbitrator's duty to protect account information on request stays account-information-protection-only, also not counted.
  • protective-order-or-confidentiality-agreement — 3 documents — The parties are to seek a protective order or make a confidentiality agreement.
  • award-only — 1 document — Only the award is confidential.
  • confidentiality-rules-referenced-not-stated — 1 document — The document refers to confidentiality rules that it does not state.
  • evidence-reuse-ban — 1 document — Evidence from one arbitration may not be used in another.
  • incorporated-terms-not-captured — 1 document (not captured) — The terms on this field are in an incorporated document that was not captured, so the field was not read.
  • mass-arbitration-mediation-only — 1 document — Only the mass-arbitration mediation is confidential.
  • not-captured — 1 document (not captured) — The arbitration agreement itself was not captured, so the field was not read.
  • partial-capture — 1 document (not captured) — The part of the document that would answer this field was not captured, so the field was not read.
Shortened limitations period
  • silent — 46 documents — The captured text has no provision on this field.
  • expressly-not-shortened — 21 documents — The document states that ordinary limitations periods apply.
  • shortened-to-1-year — 21 documents — Claims must be brought within one year.
  • shortened-to-2-years — 8 documents — Claims must be brought within two years.
  • statement-error-reporting-bar — 3 documents — The only time term is a deadline to report errors on a statement (not counted as a shortened period). — Not counted as a shortened limitations period.
  • named-state-limitations-period-applies — 2 documents — A named state's limitations period applies.
  • notice-deadline-1-year — 2 documents — Notice of a claim must be given within one year.
  • partial-capture — 2 documents (not captured) — The part of the document that would answer this field was not captured, so the field was not read.
  • disclosure-that-forum-rules-may-set-time-limits — 1 document — The document discloses that the forum's rules may set time limits.
  • incorporated-terms-not-captured — 1 document (not captured) — The terms on this field are in an incorporated document that was not captured, so the field was not read.
  • not-captured — 1 document (not captured) — The arbitration agreement itself was not captured, so the field was not read.
  • notice-deadline-2-years — 1 document — Notice of a claim must be given within two years.
  • shortened-for-specified-claims-only — 1 document — A shortened period applies to specified claims only.
Severability if the class waiver is struck
  • narrow-severance — 56 documents — Only the affected claim, class action or part leaves arbitration or is severed; the rest is arbitrated.
  • whole-clause-void-if-class-waiver-struck — 37 documents — If the class-action waiver (or the class-arbitration bar) is held unenforceable, the whole arbitration clause falls away, generally or as to the affected claims.
  • class-waiver-declared-non-severable — 6 documents — The class-action waiver is declared non-severable, without a stated consequence that voids the whole clause.
  • batching-tied-whole-clause-void — 5 documents — If the batch-arbitration provision is held unenforceable, the whole arbitration clause falls away.
  • silent — 4 documents — The captured text has no provision on this field.
  • incorporated-terms-not-captured — 1 document (not captured) — The terms on this field are in an incorporated document that was not captured, so the field was not read.
  • not-captured — 1 document (not captured) — The arbitration agreement itself was not captured, so the field was not read.
Counsel or representation restrictions
  • silent — 42 documents — The captured text has no provision on this field.
  • personal-participation-or-signature-required — 19 documents — The consumer must personally participate or sign.
  • no-agent-opt-out — 10 documents — An opt-out may not be submitted by an agent.
  • individualized-conference-required — 9 documents — A separate settlement conference is required for each claimant, even with shared counsel.
  • expressly-permits-representation — 6 documents — The document expressly permits representation by counsel.
  • authorization-to-share-account-with-counsel — 5 documents — The consumer must authorize the company to share account information with counsel.
  • counsel-certification-required — 4 documents — Counsel must sign and certify the demand.
  • no-third-party-submission — 4 documents — A notice or demand may not be submitted by a third party.
  • personal-signature-and-counsel-certification — 3 documents — The consumer must sign the demand personally, and counsel must sign or certify it.
  • individualization-and-ai-certification — 2 documents — A demand must be individualized and certify that AI-generated content was personally verified.
  • authentication-before-account-shared-with-attorney — 1 document — The consumer must authenticate and consent before the company discusses the account with an attorney.
  • authorization-to-share-account-with-counsel-dismissal-possible — 1 document — The consumer must authorize sharing with counsel, and a claim may be dismissed without it.
  • incorporated-terms-not-captured — 1 document (not captured) — The terms on this field are in an incorporated document that was not captured, so the field was not read.
  • litigation-funding-disclosure — 1 document — Parties must disclose litigation funding.
  • not-captured — 1 document (not captured) — The arbitration agreement itself was not captured, so the field was not read.
  • partial-capture — 1 document (not captured) — The part of the document that would answer this field was not captured, so the field was not read.
Mass-arbitration numeric trigger
  • no-mass-filing-terms — 46 documents
  • batching-trigger — 19 documents
  • bellwether-trigger — 17 documents
  • provider-rules-deferral — 10 documents
  • bellwether-then-release-to-court — 4 documents — After test cases and mediation, remaining claims can leave arbitration for court, either automatically or on conditions the document states, such as a party's election.
  • number-stated-procedure-deferred — 3 documents
  • filing-ban — 2 documents
  • mass-action-waiver-no-number-or-procedure — 2 documents — An express mass-action waiver with no number and no procedure.
  • coordination-trigger — 1 document
  • forum-switch-trigger — 1 document
  • group-arbitration-range — 1 document
  • hybrid-bellwether-then-batching — 1 document
  • incorporated-terms-not-captured — 1 document (not captured) — The terms on this field are in an incorporated document that was not captured, so the field was not read.
  • mass-action-waiver-with-batching-fallback — 1 document
  • not-captured — 1 document (not captured) — The arbitration agreement itself was not captured, so the field was not read.

Trigger numbers, by document (as counted):

  • 25 — 35 documents
  • 100 — 5 documents
  • 50 — 4 documents
  • 20 — 2 documents
  • 2 — 1 document
  • 5 — 1 document
  • 26 — 1 document
  • 75 — 1 document

Where the captures came from

  • company-site — 120 documents (117 families): the page as the company’s own server returned it, with the hash of the bytes as served.
  • internet-archive — 13 documents (13 families): an Internet Archive snapshot of the company’s page, which is weaker evidence of the current terms; the document’s page cites the snapshot’s own URL and states its date.
  • cfpb-database — 4 documents (3 families): the issuer’s agreement as filed in the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau’s public credit card agreement database.
  • government-site — 2 documents (2 families): a copy of the company’s document as a government agency’s server returned it, with the hash of the bytes as served; the document’s page names the site.

Each document's page says which of these its copy is. 1 document from a company's site was captured by rendering the page in a browser rather than by fetching its bytes; that copy saved only the rendered article text and says so on its page.

The text of record is the saved text a document's quotations are checked against: the capture's own text, or — where the same saved file was read again because its first text layer split or fused words — the re-extraction, which the document's page dates. The hash of the saved bytes is the same either way. 5 documents (5 families) are read from a re-extraction.

Source files

The pages are generated from these files in the research record, by name: flags_reviewed_v8.csv, thresholds_reviewed_v4.csv, clause_matrix.csv and duplicates.json and the research record's category definitions — plus each capture's text and metadata file. The reviewed CSVs carry the categories and quotations; the matrix carries the document set and its provenance; the duplicates record carries the excluded copy; the category definitions are printed on this page in their own words. No number on these pages is typed: every number is computed from those files when the site is built, and the build refuses to run if the files disagree with each other.

Requesting the data

A researcher or reporter who wants the underlying files can write to [email protected]. Company contracts on this site are quoted word for word, either from a dated copy we fetched and recorded or from a court record. A copy we fetched came from the company’s own site, from a government agency’s website such as the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau’s credit card agreement database, or from a dated archival snapshot, and each document’s page in the clause database says which. Where the report quotes a company document from a court record, it names the case. Every figure comes from a named source. If you find an error, tell us. We will check it against the source, and if we got it wrong we will correct it, date the correction, and say what changed.

This site is general information about arbitration clauses and public data about them. It is not legal advice about your situation, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Read the report